Dems Who Voted "No" On Health Reform Received $568K From Health Insurers & $377K From Drug Companies In 2009

Opponents of Reform Received 15% More In Contributions From Health Industry Than Supporters

Washington D.C. -- Democrats who voted against health care reform legislation passed on Saturday by the U.S. House of Representatives received $568,162 in campaign contributions from insurance companies and $377,943 from drug companies in just the first ten months of 2009, according to an analysis released today by Consumer Watchdog.  (See chart below).

In a related analysis, OpenSecrets.org found that opponents of the House health reform bill received 15 percent more in contributions from the broader health industry than those who supported the measure.  Read the analysis here.

"Insurers and other health care special interests have made a massive down payment to turn health care reform into a government-funded customer delivery system for the fragmented, wasteful private market.  The insurance-medical complex is spending big to eliminate the public option to the private market and reduce reform to a requirement that all Americans buy coverage with no guarantees that they will be protected when they get sick," said Jerry Flanagan of Consumer Watchdog.  "The numbers show that insurance and medical industries are hedging their bets and stacking up chips for future use by shoving money at both sides of the current debate. They're fully aware that the detailed construction of any health reform will occur after the final big votes in Congress. Money spent today will buy access as regulations and follow-up laws are passed under less scrutiny."

In a study released in July, Consumer Watchdog found that health insurers contributed $2.7 million to the top ten members in the House and Senate, while pharmaceutical companies contributed $3.4 million to the top ten members of each chamber. The two industries donated a combined $26.2 million in campaign contributions to the current members of the 111th Congress.  Read more here.

39 House Democrats and all but one of the 177 House Republicans vote against the health reform bill, HR 3962, which passed 220-215.  See the chart below for a list of contributions from insurance companies and pharmaceutical manufacturers to the Democrats opposing the measure.

- 30 -

Consumer Watchdog is a nonpartisan consumer advocacy organization with offices in Washington, D.C. and Santa Monica, CA. Find us on the web at: www.ConsumerWatchdog.org.

Rate This Article:

Comments:

Post A Comment

You are not logged in, please do so at the top of the page.

Recent Posts in Protecting Patients:

Blue Cross's taste of what's to come if health reform fails

Those of us who have health insurance--or think we have health insurance--can get complacent about whether the nation needs that big, complicated health reform legislation. But just try getting sick. Is your insurance even real? If it is, can you afford it after the latest round of price hikes? Is your deductible so big that paying it will mean financial ruin? Check out these stories and think about what the White House and Congress, by wimping out again on health reform, will condemn all of us to...

Read More »

Dateline NBC on why being insured isn't same as being covered

Here's the full link to last night's excellent Dateline NBC "Critical Condition," which followed insured patients as they were turned down by their health insurers for critical care.

Read More »

Reform or no reform, insurers will weasel on "out of network" loopholes

The Washington Post today has an eye-opening story today on how a family ended up in crushing debt at an "in-network" hospital apparently jammed with out-of-network doctors. Tens of thousands of dollars later, their little boy's rare and deadly heart defect is at least semi-fixed, but the family finances are in ruins. It's a problem that won't be fixed by reforms that rely on the private insurance industry. But it's also a problem that Congress can partly cure, with or without bigger reforms.

Read More »

MLK and the Massachusetts Senate Disaster

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said little about health care, though the one fragment that is quoted leaves no doubt about where he stood: “Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and the most inhumane.” The quote is hard to confirm, but health care proponents losing ground to a fear campaign need King's power to stoke determination in the service of hope.

Read More »

Patient protections are California's to lose

California has been a leader in patients rights, largely in response to abuses  by HMOs that, for instance, tried to eject new mothers and babies from the hospital a few hours after giving birth, and attempted to require "drive-by mastectomies."  The federal health reform bill could weaken or do away with all that, including a right to HIV/AIDS testing. Rep. Jackie Speier of San Mateo is leading a tough fight to preserve such rights, and so is Consumer Watchdog.

Read More »

View All Next »

Forward This Page To A Friend

Excerpts From Jamie Court's Dateline Interview Covering Health Insurer Hell

Heath Insurers Coercing Employees Into Political Action?