Valero 'Eve of Destruction' Was a Big Fake
Oil refiner Valero, as it pumped $5 million into a California ballot proposition aimed at killing climate change regulation, warned that such regulation would bring an economic Armageddon of lost jobs in refineries and elsewhere, as well as unaffordable energy prices.
A Consumer Watchdog study, however, proved that Valero was only interested in staving off competition from green energy companies.
The ballot measure, Proposition 23, was soundly defeated Nov. 2. You’d think, if what the Prop 23 proponents said was true, chief proposition funder Valero would take a crippling slap from the stock market. Nope, just the opposite. Its stock hit a 52-week high on Friday, and its third-quarter profit was $292 million, up nearly a billion dollars from a $691 million loss a year ago, near the bottom of the recession.
It’s true that people who work for Valero are losing jobs–the company boasts of “reducing costs” by $185 million this year, and another $100 million next year. But that’s about increasing profit, not because of climate regulation.
It’s also true that motorists, particularly in California, are paying absurdly high fuel prices. But that’s partly because of speculation-driven oil prices and partly because refiners are deliberately suppressing the amount of fuel that they refine: Profits per barrel of refined fuel are up at Valero more than 50% from last year, with similar numbers for other refiners–while the amount of capacity they are using remains far down from 2006.
The bottom line is that Valero didn’t give a darn about the effect of climate regulation on California jobs or California’s economy. The company is cutting jobs and raising profit margins because it can. And cutting out green competition would simply have made it easier.
1/24/2017News ReleaseSanta Monica, CA -- As President Trump revived the Keystone XL Pipeline, Consumer Watchdog pointed to its 2013 analysis that... More >
1/24/2017News ReleasePublic Interest Advocates Urge CA Attorney General and LA City Attorney to Investigate Natural Gas Supply Manipulation To Justify Reopening Dangerous Aliso Canyon Natural Gas Storage FacilitySanta Monica, CA — Consumer Watchdog, Food &Water Watch, and Bill Powers of Powers Engineering today urged CA... More >
2/6/2017News Release12 Public Interest Groups Find Governor Jerry Brown Is Not So Green; Lays Blame for Excess CA Electricity At His DoorSanta Monica—As Governor Jerry Brown’s regulators race to reopen Aliso Canyon without knowing what caused the biggest... More >
3/24/2017News ReleaseGovernor Jerry Brown Slams Trump Administration For Putting Interests Of Big Oil Ahead of Clean Air, Even As He Does The Same Thing In CaliforniaSanta Monica, CA— California Governor Jerry Brown has put the interests of Big Oil first in California though he criticized... More >
4/3/2017News ReleaseBig Oil Should Pay New Gas Tax Out Of Windfall Profits, Not Consumers, Consumer Watchdog Tells California LegislatureSanta Monica, CA—Governor Jerry Brown’s gas tax to fix roads should come out of oil companies’ windfall profits... More >