Consumer Watchdog Praises Judge's Decision Rejecting Proposed Settlement In Facebook "Sponsored Stories" Privacy Settlement
SANTA MONICA, CA – Consumer Watchdog praised Judge Richard Seeborg’s rejection late Friday afternoon of a proposed settlement in a class action suit against Facebook for using its users’ personal information in “Sponsored Stories” advertisements without their consent.
“This decision does much to defend the integrity of the class action process,” said John M. Simpson, Consumer Watchdog’s Privacy Project Director. “The way this deal was proposed there was no real benefit for class members.”
In his decision in Fraley v. Facebook Justice Seeborg wrote:
“In this instance there are sufficient questions regarding the proposed settlement that it would not be appropriate simply to grant the motion and postpone resolution of those issues to final approval.”
Read Settlement here: http://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/fraley_order.pdf
Consumer Watchdog had opposed the settlement saying that proposed deal “is not fair, adequate or reasonable and provides no direct or indirect benefit to class members.”
“Under the proposed settlement Facebook is poised to continue to misappropriate its users’ personal information without their consent,” wrote Laua Antonini, Consumer Watchdog staff attorney in objecting to the settlement. “Indeed, Facebook recently expanded Sponsored Stories to its mobile platform, an arena where the misappropriation of personal information has far reaching and potentially dangerous consequences; the proposed settlement does not address this major expansion.”
In his order Friday Judge Seeborg raised concerns about these area of the proposed deal:
-- The propriety of a settlement that provides no monetary relief directly to class members.
-- The amount of $10 million cy pres award, money going to charities. “Assuming that it may be appropriate to approve a settlement that provides for no cash distribution to class members in this case, the question will remain as to whether $10 million in cy pres recovery is fair, adequate, and reasonable,” the Judge wrote.
-- The injunctive relief.
-- The amount of attorney’s fees, which could total $10 million.
- 30 -
Visit our Website at www.ConsumerWatchdog.org
1/9/2014News ReleaseGoogle+ Shuts Online Predators’ Accounts In Response to Consumer Watchdog Letter, But Key Privacy Design Flaw Remains And Must Be Fixed, Public Interest Group SaysSANTA MONICA, CA – Google has cleaned up its social network shutting down some accounts of apparent online predators and... More >
3/17/2014News ReleaseSAN FRANCISCO, CA-- A federal magistrate has denied a motion from Google in the Wi-Spy class action suit that plaintiffs said... More >
3/23/2014News ReleaseWASHINGTON, DC – Consumer Watchdog today called on the U.S. Department of Justice and the Federal Communications Commission... More >
3/31/2014News ReleaseSANTA MONICA, CA – Consumer Watchdog has told the White House Team studying the Obama Administration’s policy towards... More >
4/30/2014News ReleaseSANTA MONICA, CA -- Consumer Watchdog today backed six broad policy recommendations outlined in the White House report on Big... More >